So, fairytales. Sweet, innocent little stories for children, right? Riiiiiight. But if that’s all you’re looking for, you might wanna take a sharp left. These fairytale retellings are more like “sleep-with-the-lights-on, is-love-even-real, and um… excuse me?” versions of the tales we thought we knew. It’s time to get cozy with some fairytale retellings that shatter the glass slipper, ditch the prince (or… maybe not), and dive headfirst into a world that’s dark, twisted, and oh-so-delightfully-modern.
The Dark Side of Fairytales (Cue Creepy Laugh)
If “happily ever after” feels way too predictable: we got you, fringe fam. These retellings reach deep into the shadows where the “real” fairytales live. We’re talking Wonderland with actual nightmares and stepsisters who are done with the Cinderella act.
Recommended Dark Fairytale Retellings
Alice by Christina Henry
This isn’t your cute little Alice in Wonderland. Imagine Wonderland with horror, more madness, and just a dash of trauma.
Stepsister by Jennifer Donnelly
Cinderella’s stepsister has some things to say, and she’s not pulling any punches.
The Bloody Chamber by Angela Carter
Gothic fairytales with feminist fire. Think Red Riding Hood meets… well, something a whole lot darker.
Note: These books make “happily ever after” look like a sick joke. If you’re here for nightmares disguised as fairytales, look no further. Please please check your triggers.
For the true dark fiction fans, check out our guide to Horror Classics Reinvented.
Romantic Twists that Are Actually Interesting
Not to be dramatic, but if we have to read one more “happily-ever-after” love story with zero complications, we might just… nope, can’t even say it. These are the love stories that make you question everything – the ones that are complicated, messy, and might even make you wonder if “Prince Charming” was ever really that charming.
Recommended Romantic Fairytale Retellings
The Bear and the Nightingale by Katherine Arden
Think Beauty and the Beast, but set in the freezing depths of Russian folklore. It’s all about icy tension, magic, and a romance that’ll leave you questioning what’s really dangerous.
Queen of Snow by Laura Byron and Jessie Cal
Snow White…but darker, deeper, and with way more gray (morally, that is).
Heart of the Fae by Emma Hamm
A Beauty and the Beast retelling that skips the fluff and dives into gritty Celtic folklore. Expect lush world-building, fierce chemistry, and a romance that’s far from Disney.
Note: These are not your ~true love’s kiss~ stories. Expect morally gray characters and relationships that might make you go, “ummm… is that healthy?” Check your triggers, and if there are tropes you don’t like, you simply don’t have to read!
If you love a good twisted romance, don’t miss our Fantasy Romance Picks that push the boundaries.
Modern Spins for When You’re Over the Princes and Castles
Here’s the deal: fairytales can do more than just magic mirrors and damsels in distress. In these modern retellings, fairytales are the vehicle for talking about real stuff—identity, expectations, maybe even society going off the rails.
Recommended Modern Spin Fairytale Retellings
The Mere Wife by Maria Dahvana Headley
Imagine Beowulf plopped right in the middle of American suburbia, complete with its HOA and perfectly manicured lawns. Spoiler: it’s messy, brutal, and makes you question who the real monster is.
Queen of the Conquered by Kacen Callender
Set in a world inspired by Caribbean history, it’s a sharp, dark twist on power, revenge, and the cost of getting what you want.
Spinning Silver by Naomi Novik
A darkly magical take on Rumpelstiltskin, but with enough twists and grit to keep you guessing.
Note: These aren’t just fairytales with a modern twist. They’re stories that show just how dark, chaotic, and downright brutal happily ever after can really get. Check your triggers please.
Ever wonder how fairytales reveal deeper truths about society? For a thought-provoking look into the social and political layers hidden in these classic tales, check out this fascinating podcast episode with Dr. Jack Zipes, a leading expert in folklore.
Listen to “Fairytales and Their Social and Political Implications” on Fabric of Folklore
Why Do We Love Twisted Fairytales?
Because, let’s be real, the original fairytales were never the happily-ever-after fluff they were made out to be. They were dark, twisted, and honestly… relatable? These retellings bring that original energy back, forcing us to question what’s real, what’s right, and what happens when the prince isn’t so charming after all.
Ready for Even More? Join Our Fable Book Club!
If this dive into twisted fairytales has you hooked, come join us on Fable—where we’re building a club for lovers of the weird, the subversive, and the stories that make us go “…wait, what?” Track your reads, talk theories, and let’s get real about fairytales, horror, and all things off the beaten path.
So, Which Twisted Tale Will You Pick?
What’s calling your name? A dark fairytale where happy endings are optional? A romance that makes you rethink love? Or a modern twist that brings the fantasy into our world? Comment below with your favorite subversive retelling or tell us what’s getting added to your TBR stack.
Check our more genre spotlights and opinion pieces from us!